Your daughter used to call you every night. Now she won’t pick up. When she does come for your weekend, she’s rigid and rehearsed, and she says things that sound like they came out of an adult’s mouth. You mention it to your ex, who tells you the kids are just old enough to have opinions now.
If that’s your life right now, you’re not imagining things, and you’re also not the first parent in Newport News J&DR Court to sit across from a judge trying to explain it.
Here’s what most articles on this topic get wrong: Virginia has no statute that uses the phrase “parental alienation.” There’s no cause of action to file, no box to check. What Virginia does have is a set of best-interest factors that give a judge real room to act, and knowing which ones matter changes how you build your case.
What parental alienation actually means in a custody case
Strip away the clinical language and it describes a pattern: one parent’s words or conduct steadily push a child toward rejecting the other parent, and the rejection isn’t proportionate to anything the rejected parent has done.
It shows up in ways that look small in isolation. Scheduling a birthday party during your parenting time. Telling a nine-year-old the family can’t afford groceries because of “what your father did.” Handing a child the court paperwork to read. Letting a twelve-year-old decide whether the exchange happens.
None of those is a crime. Stacked over eighteen months, they’re a pattern, and a pattern is what a judge can act on.
The clinical side is genuinely unsettled, and you should know that going in. Parental alienation is not a diagnosis in the DSM-5-TR. A psychologist can testify about what they observed and what it suggests, but no one is going to hand the court a diagnosis that decides the case. Virginia judges treat this as evidence, not as a label.
Virginia has no parental alienation statute, and that matters
Only a handful of states name parental alienation directly in statute. Virginia isn’t one of them. Virginia also hasn’t adopted the restrictions on court-ordered reunification therapy that states like New Jersey and Colorado have passed in the last few years under the federal Keeping Children Safe from Family Violence Act.
Practically, that cuts two ways for you.
The good news is that a Virginia judge has broad discretion here and isn’t boxed in by a narrow statutory definition. The harder news is that you can’t just say the words and expect the court to move. You have to connect the conduct to the statutory factors the judge is legally required to weigh.
That’s the whole game, and it comes down to two factors in particular.
The two factors that do the real work: § 20-124.3(6) and (7)
Virginia Code § 20-124.3 lists ten factors a court must consider in any custody or visitation decision. Two of them are built for exactly this situation.
Factor 6 requires the court to consider the propensity of each parent to actively support the child’s contact and relationship with the other parent, including whether a parent has unreasonably denied the other parent access to or visitation with the child.
Factor 7 requires the court to consider the relative willingness and demonstrated ability of each parent to maintain a close and continuing relationship with the child and the ability of each parent to cooperate in and resolve disputes regarding matters affecting the child.
Read those twice. Factor 6 is about interference. Factor 7 is about cooperation. A parent who blocks phone calls is a factor 6 problem. A parent who technically follows the order but refuses to communicate about the child’s asthma medication is a factor 7 problem. Most real cases involve both.
There’s more on how a judge weighs the full ten in our guide to how child custody is determined in Virginia.
When safety is the real reason a child pulls away
This part gets left out of nearly every article on the subject, and leaving it out does parents a disservice.
Factor 9 of § 20-124.3 covers any history of family abuse as defined in § 16.1-228, sexual abuse, child abuse, or an act of violence, force, or threat under § 19.2-152.7:1 occurring no earlier than ten years before the petition was filed. And the statute says something specific about what happens next: if the court finds such a history, the court may disregard the factors in subdivision 6.
That’s the legislature drawing a line. A parent who restricts contact because of a documented history of abuse is not in the same position as a parent who restricts contact for no reason, and the court is expressly permitted to set factor 6 aside.
So if you’re the parent raising alienation, expect the other side to raise safety. And if you’re the parent being accused of alienation because you limited contact after something genuinely happened, factor 9 is the provision you need in front of the judge.
How to document it without making things worse
Judges see many parents who feel wronged. What separates a case that moves from one that doesn’t is usually the quality of the record.
Keep a dated log. One line per incident: what happened, when, and who was present. Not your feelings about it. A log that reads like a diary loses credibility fast; one that reads like a flight log doesn’t.
Save the messages exactly as they came in, screenshots and all, and don’t delete your own replies even when they’re not your finest work. Selective records get noticed.
Show up for every single exchange, on time, even when you’re confident the child won’t be there. A pattern of missed handoffs on the other parent’s side only exists as evidence if you were standing there.
Two things not to do. Don’t record your child talking about the other parent as a way of collecting evidence; it usually reads as pressure on the child. And don’t argue your case to the child, ever. Judges are very good at spotting a kid who’s been coached, and they don’t spend much time asking which parent did the coaching first.
What a guardian ad litem does, and when one gets appointed
A guardian ad litem is an attorney appointed to represent the child’s interests. The GAL interviews the child, talks with both parents, often does home visits, and may contact teachers, therapists, and extended family before reporting to the judge. Judges are not bound by the recommendation, but many give it substantial weight.
Here’s the detail almost everyone gets wrong. Under § 16.1-266(F), where custody is in controversy and each parent is represented by counsel, the court is directed not to appoint a GAL unless it finds that the child’s interests aren’t otherwise adequately represented.
So if both of you have lawyers, a GAL isn’t automatic. Somebody has to ask and give the judge a reason. Alienation cases are one of the better reasons because a neutral who talks to the child outside both households is often the only way the court sees what’s actually happening. More on the role in our page on the guardian ad litem in a Virginia custody case.
Separately, § 20-124.2(D) lets the court order an independent mental health or psychological evaluation and decide who pays for it. In a contested alienation case, that order is often more useful than a GAL, and sometimes you want both.
A Newport News example
Say a father has alternating weekends and a Wednesday dinner under a 2024 order out of Newport News J&DR Court at 2501 Huntington Avenue. Over the following year the Wednesday dinners start getting cancelled, always for a reason: a project, a sleepover, a stomachache. Nineteen cancellations. He goes anyway, every time, and texts confirming he’s outside.
His daughter starts referring to him by his first name. She tells him she knows he “stopped paying for things,” a claim contradicted by the DCSE payment record.
He files a motion to amend. What he brings isn’t an accusation, it’s a spreadsheet: nineteen dated cancellations, nineteen “I’m here” texts, a school attendance record showing no absences on any of those Wednesdays, and the payment history. The judge appoints a GAL over the mother’s objection because the daughter’s account is directly contradicted by documents.
The father hasn’t proved his ex is a bad parent. He’s proved a pattern the court can measure against factor 6. That’s a case that moves. If you’re at the point of filing, our page on filing a motion to modify child custody in Virginia walks through the mechanics.
What a Virginia judge can actually order
The court’s authority here is direct. Under § 20-124.2(E), a Virginia court has continuing authority and jurisdiction to enter any additional orders necessary to enforce a custody order, including the power to punish as contempt any willful failure to comply.
In practice, remedies tend to escalate:
- A specific order to stop identified conduct, sometimes with a warning attached.
- Make up parenting time for what was blocked.
- Court-ordered counseling or family therapy.
- A shift in exchange logistics, including a neutral exchange location, which § 20-124.3 expressly permits at either party’s request.
- A change in legal custody so one parent can no longer stonewall on school or medical decisions.
- A change in physical custody, which happens, though it’s the far end of the scale and it requires a strong record.
A judge can also speak with the child privately under § 20-124.2:1, with the interview on the record.
To change an existing order at all, you’ll need to show a material change in circumstances since the last order and that the change you’re asking for serves the child’s best interests. A documented pattern of interference can satisfy the first part. One bad month generally won’t.
What tends not to work
Withholding child support to force compliance. Support and parenting time are separate obligations in Virginia, and doing this hands the other side a straightforward contempt case against you.
Keeping the child yourself in retaliation. That’s now two parents violating the order, and the judge stops being able to tell you apart.
Filing repeatedly over small things. Judges track who files, and a thick motions file with thin contents reads as the conflict itself rather than a remedy for it.
Waiting for the child to age out of it. Alienation tends to harden. So does the court’s read of a status quo you allowed to run for three years without objecting.
If the conflict is real but not yet entrenched, custody mediation is sometimes faster and less damaging than a contested hearing, and Virginia courts encourage it under § 20-124.2(A).
How long does it take to get back in front of a Newport News judge?
It depends on the docket and on whether the other parent contests. A motion to amend custody in Newport News J&DR Court at 2501 Huntington Avenue is commonly set out several weeks to a few months for an initial return date, with contested matters set further out for an evidentiary hearing. If a guardian ad litem is appointed, add time for the investigation. If a child is in immediate danger, that’s a different filing on a different timeline, and you should talk to an attorney the same day rather than waiting for a scheduled hearing.
If you’re dealing with a co-parent who’s turning your child against you, or you’ve been accused of it yourself, the attorneys at Holcomb Law are ready to help. We handle child custody cases across Newport News, Hampton, Yorktown, Virginia Beach, and Lynchburg, and we understand how much is at stake for you and your family. Call (757) 913-5204 or contact us online to schedule a consultation.
Learn more about our approach on our Virginia child custody lawyer page, or visit our Newport News office.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is parental alienation illegal in Virginia?
No. Virginia has no criminal statute and no separate civil claim for parental alienation, and the phrase doesn’t appear anywhere in the Code of Virginia. What Virginia has is Virginia Code § 20-124.3, which requires a judge deciding custody to consider each parent’s propensity to actively support the child’s relationship with the other parent, and whether a parent has unreasonably denied the other parent access to the child. So alienating conduct isn’t a crime, but it’s evidence a judge is legally required to weigh when deciding who gets custody.
Can I lose custody if my ex accuses me of alienating the kids?
It’s possible, but an accusation by itself doesn’t do much. The court looks at the pattern, not the label, and it looks at whether your reasons for limiting contact hold up. If you’ve restricted contact because of a documented history of abuse, § 20-124.3(9) allows the judge to disregard the interference factor entirely, which is the reverse of what the accusing parent wants. If you’ve restricted contact for reasons the record doesn’t support, that’s a different conversation. Either way, get your reasons documented before you’re in front of a judge, not after.
How much proof do I need before a judge takes this seriously?
More than a feeling and less than a confession. What moves cases is a dated, boring record: missed exchanges with timestamps, message threads kept intact, school or medical records that contradict the stated excuse, and third parties who saw the same thing you did. A single blocked visit is a bad month. Nineteen blocked visits across a year with your arrival documented each time is a pattern, and a pattern is what the court can measure against the statutory factors.
My teenager says she doesn’t want to see me. Does the court make her go?
The order applies to the parents, not the child, so a judge isn’t going to hold a fifteen-year-old in contempt. But the custodial parent is still obligated to make the child available and to genuinely encourage the visit, and “she refused” wears thin as an explanation when it happens every time. Virginia courts do consider a child’s reasonable preference under § 20-124.3(8), weighing the child’s intelligence, understanding, age, and experience. A judge who suspects that preference was manufactured will often appoint a guardian ad litem or order a psychological evaluation rather than take it at face value.
Wayne E. Holcomb, Esq. | Holcomb Law, P.C. | Licensed in Virginia since 2008 | Regent University School of Law
This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Advertising material under Virginia Rules of Professional Conduct 7.1 through 7.5. Statutory citations reflect the Code of Virginia as published at law.lis.virginia.gov as of July 30, 2026, and are subject to change.


